Libera Dreams

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 5:45 pm**

illuminaperpetua wrote:
carina_gino20 wrote:Libera36 totally called it. She kept insisting it was Tom Cully on Ave Virgo. Nice job!
I knew too! I just didn't say anything cause everybody was sure it was Ed or someone else and Nicole said it couldn't have been him...that they wouldn't have recorded it earlier and then put it on another CD like they did with Steven Geraghty on Free.
but yay! I was right!

one of my favriet songs on the cd is calld Exultate and it will make you dancs i thank mini ben sings this song i have not heard of it befor its really nice i like it a lot it makes your day more fun and i thank you can sing a long with it

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 5:53 pm**

Yorkie wrote:

that's stupid! he looks like he's popping out of the box or something!

and what was wrong with Ed, that they should remove him?? I don't think it looks any "prettier"

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 6:03 pm**

irishoreo wrote:I'm seriously hoping, has Tom had mentioned, that it's just some arsehole who photoshopped that and did so to cause a reaction

I just totally read that wrong! lol "arisole"

I'm so smart!

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 6:07 pm**

What is done is done

. I am really shocked at peoples reaction over this. I honestly dont see what the big deal is.

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 6:09 pm**

dani wrote:What is done is done . I am really shocked at peoples reaction over this. I honestly dont see what the big deal is.

me ither dani i wish people can see the happy nesss of libera and not worrying a bout ed in the picuter my be ed is looking at josh WHILE HE IS SMIELING ON IT

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 6:14 pm**

jennaluvspbr wrote:
dani wrote:What is done is done . I am really shocked at peoples reaction over this. I honestly dont see what the big deal is.
me ither dani i wish people can see the happy nesss of libera and not worrying a bout ed in the picuter my be ed is looking at josh WHILE HE IS SMIELING ON IT

Glad i am not alone in this, lets just enjoy the new album and stop worring about a random picture that we can not change.

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 7:26 pm**

dani wrote:
jennaluvspbr wrote:
dani wrote:What is done is done . I am really shocked at peoples reaction over this. I honestly dont see what the big deal is.
me ither dani i wish people can see the happy nesss of libera and not worrying a bout ed in the picuter my be ed is looking at josh WHILE HE IS SMIELING ON IT
Glad i am not alone in this, lets just enjoy the new album and stop worring about a random picture that we can not change.

right and we fans need to be happy for libera and all of it

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 7:34 pm**

dani wrote:
jennaluvspbr wrote:
dani wrote:What is done is done . I am really shocked at peoples reaction over this. I honestly dont see what the big deal is.
me ither dani i wish people can see the happy nesss of libera and not worrying a bout ed in the picuter my be ed is looking at josh WHILE HE IS SMIELING ON IT
Glad i am not alone in this, lets just enjoy the new album and stop worring about a random picture that we can not change.

My upset over this is because as a teen and recently as an adult, I found myself "edited" out. The re-enactment video may have been just time constrictions but the incident from high school was a deliberate act of my director to have his only french horn player not in the encore.
I guess if one has never been "edited" out of something, one can't really understand the hurt that comes along with it. That is why, as a moderator here, I have never edited anyone posts but talk to them via pm about it.
But, I guess it is time to move on. There will be no more comments from me on this subject.

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 8:39 pm**

TEB wrote:I guess if one has never been "edited" out of something, one can't really understand the hurt that comes along with it.

Oh, I don't know if that's quite right--I'm sure that Dani and Jenna are empathetic enough to understand where you're coming from. I'm so sorry that that happened to you, truly. The opinions about this topic vary with our subjective perceptions of the situation, though, so a little dissent makes sense! I love that there is so much individuality in this forum. I like hearing different sides of this issue.

I guess I just wish we had a little more context to explain the change. I want to believe there's a very logical explanation that we haven't heard yet.

Posted: **Sat Mar 06, 2010 10:13 pm**

Flora wrote:
TEB wrote:I guess if one has never been "edited" out of something, one can't really understand the hurt that comes along with it.
Oh, I don't know if that's quite right--I'm sure that Dani and Jenna are empathetic enough to understand where you're coming from. I'm so sorry that that happened to you, truly. The opinions about this topic vary with our subjective perceptions of the situation, though, so a little dissent makes sense! I love that there is so much individuality in this forum. I like hearing different sides of this issue.

I guess I just wish we had a little more context to explain the change. I want to believe there's a very logical explanation that we haven't heard yet.

So do I Flora, so do I. Unfortunately similar incidents have happened to me a few years ago which is why I agree with Tom sooo much. But I will be taking a page out of Tom's book; I will not comment on that subject anymore as well.

Posted: **Sun Mar 07, 2010 3:02 am**

I hope Ed won't think the photo issue as a big deal and will keep singing in Libera happily and keeping his friendship with everyone in Libera. Keep singing Ed Day!

Posted: **Sun Mar 07, 2010 3:37 am**

alicealc wrote:I hope Ed won't think the photo issue as a big deal and will keep singing in Libera happily and keeping his friendship with everyone in Libera. Keep singing Ed Day!

Yes! Exactly! Keep on singing, Ed!

Posted: **Sun Mar 07, 2010 5:17 am**

illuminaperpetua wrote:
Yorkie wrote:
that's stupid! he looks like he's popping out of the box or something! and what was wrong with Ed, that they should remove him?? I don't think it looks any "prettier"

I have to agree with you on this one. Jakob looks like he popped out of the step.

It looked more natural with Ed since we can see his elbow and arm resting in front of him.

Posted: **Sun Mar 07, 2010 6:25 am**

Nikki178 wrote:
illuminaperpetua wrote:
Yorkie wrote:
that's stupid! he looks like he's popping out of the box or something! and what was wrong with Ed, that they should remove him?? I don't think it looks any "prettier"
I have to agree with you on this one. Jakob looks like he popped out of the step. It looked more natural with Ed since we can see his elbow and arm resting in front of him.

That is called an Epic Fail in Photoshop world

Posted: **Sun Mar 07, 2010 8:40 am**

paopao wrote:That is called an Epic Fail in Photoshop world

I think that we can all agree on. In terms of technical merit, it's a big fat zero!

I personally feel people are being over sensitive to the reasons undelying the change, and maybe reading too much into it,but I can understand their right to express their concerns.

That will also be the final word from me on this subject.

Peace!