Moderator: Moderators
Unless they are well developed for 2 or 3 year oldsTullyBascombe wrote:The birthdays listed for Matthew Jensen, Matthew Madine and Eoghan McCarthy are obviously wrong.
Well, it does not matter how many resources you have, as long as the birthdays are not published officially, as long they are not credible.Sue wrote:This side isn't the only source,
This has nothing to do with 'opinion' but with 'fact'. Please keep in mind, that one of our tasks in this forum is to keep it credible and trustworthy - and this can, related to the date of birth, only be made with facts and not with a 'possible truth'. Therefore are some of your published data possible - but not more.Sue wrote:That is your opinion & I have mine.
The link actually lists Matthew Jansen twice, with 2 diferent birthdates.Sue wrote:This side isn't the only source,
Matt Madine 15th November 2001
Eoghan McCarthy 15th August 2000
For Matt Jensen, the month & year is right, the exact day isn't sure.
Do you know where that page went? I was thinking recently that someone should send that data to whomever operates the Libera Database listed in the Webpages section linked to Libera Dreams home page.Sue wrote:Looks like the Thomas Delgado-secret is out.
I asked thousands of Libera-fans on facebook and really, two of them were able to answer. So, with you there are 3 who said 2002.
One of them could show me a source, there was a page on Libera 360 network. It's no longer online but she could send me this cache page http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/s ... event%3D44
Also interesting there are some birthday dates of other Libera newbies
So Thomas Delgado was born on 3rd January 2002.
The boy second from the right in your photo line-up looks like Bertie Smart rather than any one of the boys you have named Sue. FYI one of the new boys is black so I think you have missed his photo and included Bertie by mistake. I can't help identify which boy is which though for the other newbies.Sue wrote:The Libera November 2012 newbies!
Camden Stewart,
Alex Montoro,
Marc Alvares,
Anthony Kerr-Munley,
Alessandro MacKinnon-Botti
At the moment I can't put the faces to the right names, maybe some of you can?
I haven't seen a black boy in the photos of November 2012, where was he?Yorkie wrote:FYI one of the new boys is black so I think you have missed his photo. I can't help identify which boy is which though for the other newbies.Sue wrote:The Libera November 2012 newbies!
Camden Stewart,
Alex Montoro,
Marc Alvares,
Anthony Kerr-Munley,
Alessandro MacKinnon-Botti
At the moment I can't put the faces to the right names, maybe some of you can?
Now, I might well be old,fat and a little stupid but I'm sure I'm not yet blind! He wasn't one of the two lads who went to NI but he was one of the three who appeard at St George's for the first time.Sue wrote: I haven't seen a black boy in the photos of November 2012, where was he?
As I remember we had the two newbies from NI - Anthony and Alessandro - then two newbies for the first time on a concert (don't remember the names) and then three newbies for the first time on stage and not on all songs. And one of them was black boy.Yorkie wrote:Now, I might well be old,fat and a little stupid but I'm sure I'm not yet blind! He wasn't one of the two lads who went to NI but he was one of the three who appeard at St George's for the first time.Sue wrote: I haven't seen a black boy in the photos of November 2012, where was he?
He did actually appear in one or two photos but I'm not sure whe took the photo or where it was posted........
