Libera Members Time Line

[Amie_Hill]

...and some more

[bamboo]

Whichever way we look at this, it's a little unnerving as it seems these people got a lot correct, as we still aren't agreed for the boy we're naming Matthew Horsewood. Maybe he is actually Matthew Winter? What does everyone think? Some proposals below.

Our confirmed picture of Matthew Winter by Ben Crawley is here, but the original has been compressed vertically which makes his face slightly fatter than it should be. I've modified it by the same amount as I have for a very well known face in that video to get the dimensions correct. This is what is gives :



Photos from late 1998, 1998, 1999, 2001

This is Matthew Winter in 2014:

Taken from: https://www.facebook.com/matt.winter.18

I'm quite sure this is the exact Matthew Winter that sang in Angel Voices because he's a friend of Andy Winter (whose profile matches the photos fans took with him at one of the concerts in Philippines). See any similarities with his younger version?

[The Furby]

Thanks you Amie for your captures

Wow! Thank you bamboo
I can see adult Matthew has this more rounded head like the older boy in the last photo.
I had already seen some similarities but in opinion that settles it.

[Dinedorelle]

bamboo That was a pretty spectacular find!
You sent me on a roller coaster though....... you said 2004 in your post.
I looked at his picture and thought - that's definitely him - but not 3 years after the Luminosa picture surely? He had stubble. Impossible!
I checked the post on FB, and it said 2014. Phew

That's not all though, because if you go a bit deeper into his public profile, Ron, Andy and Clive Winter are mentioned, as well as Ian Tilley (who apparently lives outside the UK now), Chris Turner, Anthony Chadney and Simon Lewis.
This is going to take some decent looking into.

That was a classic find bamboo. Great work
Btw, I agree entirely with The Furby, in saying that it's him, Matthew Winter.

[Dinedorelle]

Putting this one down in the history book then in 2020 as confirmed by images

MATTHEW WINTER 1998-2002

[Dinedorelle]

And to keep the ball rolling...

Does anyone think these two are the same person, possibly 4-5 years apart?

[bamboo]

bamboo That was a pretty spectacular find!
You sent me on a roller coaster though....... you said 2004 in your post.
I looked at his picture and thought - that's definitely him - but not 3 years after the Luminosa picture surely? He had stubble. Impossible!
I checked the post on FB, and it said 2014. Phew

That's not all though, because if you go a bit deeper into his public profile, Ron, Andy and Clive Winter are mentioned, as well as Ian Tilley (who apparently lives outside the UK now), Chris Turner, Anthony Chadney and Simon Lewis.
This is going to take some decent looking into.

That was a classic find bamboo. Great work
Btw, I agree entirely with The Furby, in saying that it's him, Matthew Winter.

Oops my bad! Yep, I looked into Andy, Clive, Ian, Chris and Anthony. But most of them don't have their friend list and most of their photos public, so tis hard to find out what they really looked like when they were younger. I managed to find Joe Platt & Joe Sanders-Wilde too. Joe Sanders-Wilde facial features are recognizable but Joe Platt doesn't have any photos visible to public So the Matthew Horsewood-Joe Platt saga can't end yet!

[bamboo]

According to one source that would be Daren Geraghty. He looks like an older Daren but there's further no telling of Daren
being with Libera / Angel Voices in 2001 which is the year of that video.

Btw, just in case you are wondering how Daren looks like now... Here he is on the right:

[The Furby]

Just came across the Angel Voices sleeve when going through my scans of SPBC/Angel Voices CDs & tapes.
I've never looked carefully at these few pics before - just noted the one with the grey robes surrounding Alan Titchmarsh.
Many faces already seen in 92-93 videos

[Amie_Hill]

Top: Alex Baron and Chris Turner
Middle: Ian Tilley as a chorister/adult
Bottom: Andy Winter in 2013 (photo by Orangecat)

[Amie_Hill]

Top: Anthony Chadney
Middle: Alistair Gordon
Bottom: Joe Platt

Google Image is a great tool for finding photos; just enter Libera+boy's name.

Screen Shot 2020-02-29 at 11.08.46 AM.png (202.61 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

Screen Shot 2020-02-29 at 11.08.46 AM.png (202.61 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

Screen Shot 2020-02-27 at 3.04.23 PM.png (61.58 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

Screen Shot 2020-02-27 at 3.04.23 PM.png (61.58 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

Screen Shot 2020-02-29 at 11.09.12 AM.png (127.44 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

Screen Shot 2020-02-29 at 11.09.12 AM.png (127.44 KiB) Viewed 10842 times

[Amie_Hill]

Oh yes, and I believe this is Matthew Arthey.

[Dinedorelle]

Quick Quiz : who's this boy who's quite literally been hiding in the shadows for 19 years, poor thing?! He's pretty well known.

[Dinedorelle]

And to keep the ball rolling...

Does anyone think these two are the same person, possibly 4-5 years apart?

Pretty innocuous little post actually, but have a good close look at these two. I think they're the same boy - our BOY C, who we haven't yet been able to name correctly.
We thought it was originally Jake Shortall, until we realised the original name list that came with the Luminosa photo sleeve may have been flawed, and their names would have been speculation at the time (Liberation confirmed).

I didn't just choose any old random image to compare him to though - this is an image from a Facebook page owned by a Matthew Horsewood.
Looks like he's maybe off to the school prom in the original, so it would make the photos maybe 4/5 years apart.

If we agree it's him, he doesn't appear in any image, video or document the year before or the year after 2001, so it seems he was a Newbie, and left in 2001.

[Dinedorelle]

I'm trying to identify the year that Daren Geraghty joined the group.
The forums seem to indicate 1992/3 when he started singing solos and so was named on albums like Angels (1993).

However, I have a sneaking suspicion he started singing a few years earlier in 1990.

This is the cover of 'New Day', the Angels album released in 1990. I've arrowed one of the boys that's sitting to the left of Robert Chee-a-Tow in the group photo, and remastered the photo to get this.



Robert was probably 10 or 11 there and this boy looks a fair bit younger, maybe 7 or 8? The years fit and there's an 18 months difference in the two photos above.
Also, the progression of younger members is quite clear into 1993. I've matched them all up, and the only other boy it could be is a younger Luke Avery who has a completely different haircut.
So this is either Daren, or a boy who appeared in the photoshoot then left Angel Voices fairly quickly afterwards.